| Platinum | Smash Kitchen & Bar |
| Gold | Five Guys |
| Silver | Super Smash Burgs |
| Bronze | The Duchess Of Markham |
| Top Pick | Allstar Wings & Ribs |
| Top Pick | Fresh Burger |
| Top Pick | Good Catch Boil House |
| Top Pick | Ithaca Greek Mediterranean Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Unionville Arms Pub & Grill |
| Top Pick | Wimpy's Diner |