| Platinum | Smash Kitchen & Bar |
| Gold | Ithaca Greek Mediterranean Restaurant |
| Silver | Fresh Burger |
| Bronze | Jake's on Main |
| Top Pick | Cora's |
| Top Pick | Golden Star Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Super Smash Burgs |
| Top Pick | Turtle Jack's Vogell |
| Top Pick | Unionville Arms Pub & Grill |